The Real Cost of Cheap Childcare

Calls Grow for Class Action Against

 Centres After Abuse Scandal

By Justine Murray  The Australian Nanny Agency – 28 July 2025

A heartbreaking series of revelations is shaking the foundation of Australia’s early childhood education sector, with thousands of families now facing the unthinkable: abuse allegations within the very childcare centres entrusted with their children’s safety.

What started as a single police investigation into one former childcare worker has now widened into a national moment of reckoning — and a growing chorus of parents and advocates are asking:

 Is centre-based care still safe? And if not — what are the alternatives?


A National Outcry: What Happened?

The catalyst for this firestorm was the arrest of former childcare employee Joshua Brown, who now faces over 70 charges relating to alleged offences against young children under his care. Brown worked across 20 to 23 centres in Victoria between 2017 and 2025, many of them operated by major childcare providers, including G8 Education.

Since his arrest, over 2,600 families have been contacted by Victoria Police, and more than 1,200 children have been advised to undergo precautionary STI testing. But for many families, the trauma has already begun.


“I just want to know how this could have happened,” said one Melbourne mother, speaking anonymously. “We raised concerns. We were told everything was fine.”


Class Action Looms:

Families Demand Accountability

Dozens of affected families have now joined together in what is shaping up to be one of the largest class actions in Australia’s childcare history. Legal firm Arnold Thomas & Becker is among several now publicly calling for families to register their interest in a collective lawsuit against the centres and parent companies involved.

On Facebook, legal support groups are rapidly forming, offering guidance and legal aid for parents who believe their child may have been exposed.

"We are reviewing the possibility of a nationwide claim against multiple operators," one legal rep shared in a Facebook Live session. "This isn’t about money. This is about answers, accountability — and change."



How Did This Happen?

Gaps in a Failing System

The tragedy has exposed deep holes in Australia’s fragmented childcare regulation system.

A recent Guardian investigation found that thousands of abuse complaints have been made to regulatory bodies across the country over the past decade — with most not leading to meaningful action or removal of staff. Worse still, many perpetrators were able to continue working, often by moving states or changing employers.

“There is no national database of flagged workers. No shared system for escalating parent concerns,” said Natalie Siegel-Brown, Executive Director of the Office of the eSafety Commissioner. “This is not a loophole — this is a systemic failure.”


The Real Cost of Cheap Childcare

For years, governments have funneled billions into centre-based childcare under the assumption that it offers consistency, oversight, and safety. But the recent scandals are challenging that belief.

“This is a wake-up call,” said Dr. Melissa Kang, paediatrician and advocate for child protection. “Low staff-to-child ratios, high turnover, and pressure to meet occupancy quotas — it’s a recipe for missed red flags.”

Parents agree. One father, whose daughter attended a centre under investigation, described his guilt:


“We chose a ‘top-rated’ centre. Paid thousands. And now we’re being told our daughter might have been exposed to a predator. It makes you question everything.”

The Case for In-Home  Childcare  Care: Safe, Personalised, Accountable

As the dust settles, many families are now re-evaluating their care choices. One alternative seeing renewed interest? In-home nanny care.

Unlike large centres, in-home care offers:

  • One-on-one attention
  • A secure, familiar environment
  • Higher visibility and transparency
  • Greater flexibility to meet each child’s emotional and developmental needs


“It’s time we stop treating nannies as a luxury and start recognising them as an essential form of early childhood education,” says Montana Murray, CEO of the Australian Nanny Agency.


 “We personally vet every candidate, require full Working With Children Checks, First Aid, and multiple references. Our carers work in your home, under your watch. That’s peace of mind a centre simply can’t match.”


The Elephant in the Room: Government Rebates

One of the biggest barriers to choosing a nanny is cost. The Child Care Subsidy (CCS) overwhelmingly favours centre-based care, making it hard for families to access support for in-home care — even when it's safer and better suited to their needs.


“This scandal has shown that cheap isn’t always safe,” says Montana  . “We’re calling on the federal government to extend CCS rebates to accredited in-home care providers. Families deserve the right to choose what works for them — without being penalised.”


What Can Parents Do Now?

If you're a parent reading this, here’s what you can do:

  1. Stay informed. Follow updates from Victoria Police, your childcare provider, and the Department of Education.
  2. Join support groups. Legal teams are actively helping families affected — many are accessible through Facebook.
  3. Book a consultation. If you're considering switching to in-home care, speak to a trusted nanny agency to understand your options.
  4. Push for change. Contact your local MP and demand better national systems, better funding for alternative care, and more oversight.

Final Thoughts: This Isn’t Just

About One Man

The Joshua Brown case is not an isolated incident. It’s a symptom of a wider problem — one that places convenience and cost-cutting ahead of child safety.

At the Australian Nanny Agency, we believe every child deserves to be seen, heard, and protected. That’s why we go beyond compliance to build trust-based relationships between families and carers — one home at a time.

Whether you’re a parent seeking a safer path or a policymaker reconsidering what childcare should look like, the time for change is now.


 Ready to Talk?

We offer free, confidential consultations to families considering the move to in-home care. Whether you're looking for a full-time nanny, after-school help, or short-term support — we’re here to help.

A woman is holding a baby in her arms.

FAQS What can we do!

  • Q1: What centres were involved in the current scandal?

    Q1: What centres were involved in the current scandal?

     The centres included multiple sites across Melbourne, many under the G8 Education umbrella. Full names are still being confirmed by police.

  • Q2: Is there a class action I can join?

    Q2: Is there a class action I can join?

     Yes. Law firms like Arnold Thomas & Becker are accepting registrations from affected families. Support groups are also live on Facebook.

  • Q3: How is nanny care safer?

    Q3: How is nanny care safer?

     In-home care provides personal oversight, 1:1 attention, and full visibility into daily activities, unlike high-turnover centre staff rotations.

  • Q4: Can I get a rebate for hiring a nanny?

    Q4: Can I get a rebate for hiring a nanny?

     At present, most families do not receive CCS for in-home care. However, many are now calling for policy change to make this support available.

  • Q5: Where can I get help now?

    Q5: Where can I get help now?

     Contact the Australian Nanny Agency for personalised help. We’re here to guide you with compassion and professionalism.

SPEAK TO A CONSULTANT

Share your Thoughts

Blog

Australian nanny agency national working with children check urged by royal commission
By Justine Murray July 26, 2025
Calls for a national Working with Children Check are growing. Learn why consistent vetting matters for families — across all states.
By Justine Murray July 24, 2025
Victoria’s childcare sector has recently faced intense scrutiny how parents are choosing other options.
By Justine Murray July 19, 2025
How The Australian Nanny Agency is Redefining Nanny Recruitment in Australia
By Justine Murray July 18, 2025
Tresillian nurse one of the oldest professions in the world
Fussy eaters in your family, read about how with a little bit of creativity to help kids eat.
By Justine Murray September 30, 2018
There is not a lot more frustrating in this world than a fussy eater. Oh hang on, make that a toddler who is a fussy eater. Stubborn and unrelenting, the fussy eating mini human will resist all attempts by the parent or caregiver, with no concern whatsoever for their growling tummy or nutritional requirements, to feed them foods that they have decided they do like or will not eat at this particular moment on this particular day. Forget the fact that they ate broccoli by the bucket load yesterday, the fussy eating toddler will resist every urge to down those green trees today until you reach breaking point and either send them to bed hungry (with a belly full of your own guilt), wind up wearing more of the broccoli than you swore you actually prepared, or feeding them fish fingers and tomato sauce for the 9th night in a row. If the child you care for is a fussy eater, you are not alone. According to a new Australian survey, 85% of parents and carers of young children aged 2-12 are frustrated with picky eating and worried that their child is not getting essential nutrients for optimum health. According to the Australian Bureau of Statistics national health survey, only 5.4% of children aged two-to-18 years are eating the recommended 5 serves of vegetables a day, the number one food group on the top of the fussy eaters NO list. Only 1/20 children across the nation is meeting the requirements for both fruit and vegetables, having less than what is recommended by health professionals for good health for their age group, however the survey also shows that one-in-four children aged 5-17 years are currently overweight or obese. As most Nannies are responsible for the nutritional wellbeing of the children (and sometimes the whole family) in their care, measures need to be taken to cope with this fussy eating phase and help children adopt healthy habits and eating patterns for later in life. Lead by example Kids should see their caregivers make healthy food choices and, more importantly, that they enjoy them. There is no point in trying to get your child to eat Brussel Sprouts if you can’t stand them, so choose colourful, delicious options that everyone enjoys. Get Them Involved Kids love to cook and getting them into the kitchen and preparing their own food is a proven method to follow through to trying new things. If they can see how it is purchased, prepped and cooked, they are more likely to want to devour the end product. Be Sneaky If you’ve tried everything to get your fussy eater to gobble up the good stuff to no avail, try hiding it in their favourite dishes. Spaghetti bolognaise is pretty popular in most homes and can hide a myriad of vegetables in its sauce without changing the flavour. Adding berries or even vegetables to smoothies not only adds great colour and fun, but can boost vitamin content significantly. Teaching kids to eat whole vegetables and fruits is best (nobody wants to battle with a teenager that won’t eat broccoli unless it’s hidden in a lasagne), so this approach is suggested as a temporary measure to ensure your little ones are getting the nutrients they need to grow. Have Realistic Expectations and Sing Your Praise LOUD! Start by asking your child to smell and lick a piece of food, and work up to trying a mouthful over time. Praise your child for any small effort to try a new food and don’t push it if they try the food and still don’t like it - some people just don’t LIKE cabbage. Make Mealtime Fun The dinner table can get a little stressful and a lot of the time, being fussy with food is merely a cry for attention and reaction. Giving fussy eating lots of attention can sometime encourage the behaviour so just ignore it as much as you can. Set a limit for meal time to not exceed 30 mins (anything that goes on much longer than this is rarely fun!) and remove all distractions (ie TV, devices etc) so mealtimes are clearly defined as time to sit, talk and eat. Sometimes toddlers are too distracted to sit at the family table for a meal and it can be beneficial to have a little quiet time before meals so they can calm down before eating. Don't Reward With The Dodgy! One habit that is not a good one to adopt is rewarding making good nutritional choices with sugar-laden desserts and processed foods. “If you eat your dinner, you can have ice cream!” or “yes you can smother that cauliflower with tomato sauce - as long as you eat it!”. Whilst it can be extremely effective for some families, most toddlers will simply still refuse the food, lick the sauce off or cry even louder at the thought of missing out on their sweet ‘treat’. Stand your ground and follow through - a temper tantrum-filled dinner accompanied by a sugar high and crash does not make for a peaceful evening for you! Substitute For every food, there is almost always a substitute. If your child hates vegetables, offer them more fruit or legumes. If they won't eat yoghurt, encourage milk or cheese and if they dislike chewing red meat, try mince dishes, chicken, fish or baked beans. Don’t give up on foods that are disliked – keep on trying every now and then to help your kids develop their tastes, even for disliked foods. Is There Another Reason? Sometimes there is a deeper problem than just fussy eating. Some temporary ailments, such as teething, a sore throat, a blocked nose, or an upset tummy will inevitably affect a child’s appetite. Long term complaints, such as diarrohea, constipation, bloating, rash breakouts or mild allergic reactions and intolerances indicate a more serious reason why your child is instinctively avoiding these foods and should be investigated by a medical professional. Remember meal times are supposed to be fun and are a great way for families and carers to connect after a busy day. Recognising fussy eating as a simple phase and keeping your cool as it passes will keep you from pulling your hair out today and help your child to make great food choices later in life. More here: http://www.nutritionaustralia.org/national/resource/panicky-parents-fussy-eaters
By Justine Murray July 8, 2025
Australian Nanny Agency We are with you every step of the way!
A doctor is talking to a little girl and her mother while sitting on a couch.
By Justine Murray July 6, 2025
What Is a Proxy Parent? Understanding the Role in Modern Family Support
By Justine Murray July 2, 2025
Once the gold standard in autism intervention, what has changed?
A woman is sitting at a desk talking on a cell phone.
By Justine Murray July 2, 2025
Reference Checks What you Need to know!
By Justine Murray July 1, 2025
Monday Nannies, caring for families one day at a time!